Why Most Public Speaking Advice Is Actually Making Your Fear Worse

You know what really winds me up about the public speaking industry? The fact that 78% of the so-called "experts" are still peddling the same tired advice that would've been fresh back when Nokia phones had snake games on them.

Here's what happened to me three years ago at a leadership conference in Sydney. I'm sitting in the back row, watching this motivational speaker tell 200 business professionals to "imagine their audience in their underwear" and "just pretend you're talking to one person." The bloke next to me - turns out he was a senior manager at Commonwealth Bank - leans over and whispers, "This is exactly why I still break out in hives before every board presentation."

That moment crystallised something I'd been thinking about for ages. We're approaching public speaking fear all wrong.

The Problem With Traditional Advice

Most public speaking training treats fear like it's some character flaw you need to overcome through willpower and breathing exercises. Rubbish. Fear of public speaking isn't a weakness - it's your brain doing exactly what evolution designed it to do. When our ancestors stood up in front of the tribe and said something unpopular, they literally got cast out and died.

Your amygdala doesn't know the difference between a hostile caveman audience and your quarterly sales presentation. It just knows: "Big group watching = potential social death = actual death = PANIC NOW."

So when some trainer tells you to "just relax and be yourself," they're essentially asking you to override millions of years of survival programming with positive thinking. Good luck with that.

What Actually Works (And Why Nobody Talks About It)

Here's something that'll ruffle feathers: The best public speakers I know aren't fearless. They're terrified. The difference is they've learned to work with their fear instead of against it.

I learned this from working with a Brisbane-based CEO who runs a $50 million construction company. Bloke's built his entire business through networking and presentations, right? Turns out he still gets nervous before every single speaking engagement. But he's discovered something brilliant: his nervous energy makes him sharper, more focused, more authentic.

He told me, "When I stopped trying to eliminate the nerves and started channelling them into passion for my message, everything changed." Now he deliberately gets himself a bit worked up before important presentations because he knows it gives him an edge.

The Three Things Nobody Tells You

First truth: Your audience wants you to succeed. They're not sitting there hoping you'll fail so they can laugh at you. They're busy thinking about their own problems, their lunch plans, whether they remembered to feed the parking meter. Most people are way too self-absorbed to spend mental energy judging your presentation skills.

Second truth: Perfection is overrated and boring. Some of the most memorable presentations I've attended included technical glitches, speakers forgetting their lines, or completely going off-script. These moments made the presenter more human, more relatable.

I remember a Melbourne tech startup founder whose PowerPoint crashed five minutes into his investor pitch. Instead of panicking, he said, "Well, looks like we're doing this old school," grabbed a whiteboard marker, and delivered the most compelling product demo I've ever seen. He raised $2.3 million that day.

Third truth: The stress management you're feeling isn't stage fright - it's excitement wearing a disguise. Same physiological response, different mental frame. Professional athletes know this. They don't try to calm down before competition; they reframe their nervousness as readiness.

The Melbourne Method (That Actually Makes Sense)

About two years ago, I started testing a different approach with clients. Instead of fighting the fear, we embrace it as data. Your nervousness is telling you this presentation matters to you. That's valuable information.

Here's what I now teach:

Week one: Record yourself having normal conversations. Not practising speeches - just chatting about things you care about. Watch these back and notice how naturally articulate you are when you're not "performing."

Week two: Present your content to your reflection in a mirror, but with a twist. Every time you catch yourself being "presenter-y," stop and start again as if you're explaining it to your best mate over coffee.

Week three: Present to progressively larger groups, but always frame it as "I want to share something that excited me" rather than "I need to deliver this presentation."

The breakthrough moment usually happens in week three when people realise they've been approaching public speaking like they're defending their PhD thesis instead of sharing something they actually give a damn about.

Why Most Corporate Training Gets It Wrong

Corporate Australia spends millions on presentation skills training every year, and most of it focuses on the wrong things. They teach slide design, body language, vocal techniques - all the surface-level stuff. It's like teaching someone to paint by starting with brush technique instead of helping them find something they actually want to paint.

The companies that get it right - and I've worked with several in Perth and Adelaide - focus on message clarity first. They help their people figure out what they actually want to say before worrying about how to say it. Revolutionary concept, right?

The Unexpected Solution

Here's what's going to sound counterintuitive: the best cure for public speaking anxiety is more public speaking. Not practice - actual speaking to real audiences who have a genuine reason to hear what you're saying.

Start small. Volunteer to give updates at team meetings. Offer to present at industry meetups. Suggest speaking at your kid's school career day. The key is choosing topics you're genuinely passionate about rather than assignments you're obligated to complete.

I've seen managing difficult conversations become significantly easier for people once they've built confidence through voluntary speaking opportunities. There's something about choosing to share your expertise that changes the entire dynamic.

What I Got Wrong For Years

Time for some honesty: I used to teach people to memorise their presentations word-for-word. Terrible advice. Nothing sounds more robotic than someone reciting memorised content, and nothing creates more anxiety than worrying about forgetting your lines.

These days, I teach bullet points and stories. Know your key messages, have three good stories that illustrate each point, and trust yourself to connect the dots in real-time. Your presentation might be slightly different each time, but it'll be authentic and engaging.

The other thing I got completely wrong was telling people to "fake it til you make it." Audiences can spot fake confidence from the back row. Authentic nervousness is far more appealing than manufactured bravado.

Our Favourite Blogs:

• Label Team Further Resources
• Identity Group Posts

The Bottom Line

Public speaking fear isn't something you overcome once and forget about. It's something you learn to dance with. The most successful speakers I know - from ASX-listed company CEOs to TED talk regulars - still get nervous. They've just learned that nervousness and effectiveness aren't mutually exclusive.

Stop trying to eliminate the fear. Start asking yourself what you care enough about to feel nervous sharing it. That's where real communication begins.

And for heaven's sake, stop imagining your audience in their underwear. It's weird, it doesn't work, and it says more about the person giving that advice than it does about effective presentation skills.

The fear isn't the problem. The fear is the point. It means you care. Use it.